KENTON COM. ATTN. SUED FOR
MALACIOUS PROSECUTION
BY ACQUITTED SCHOOL TEACHER WHO WAS ALLEGED
TO HAVE HAD SEX WITH A MALE STUDENT
On Wed. Nov. 25th. Nicole Howell filed a Federal 1983 Civil Rights complaint against Kenton Commonwealth Attorney Rob Sanders. The suit claims Sanders ordered the arrest of Howell without the required “probable cause”. Kentucky law since 1993 has held that Prosecutors have a qualified immunity for acts committed during the “Investigatory Phase” of their work, but have Absolute Immunity for the “Prosecutorial Phase” of their work.
To overcome qualified immunity a litigant suing a prosecutor must prove malice and lack of probable cause. The Doctrine of Absolute Immunity is currently under attack in the U.S. Supreme Court in the Pottawatamee case. A decision by the U.S. Supreme Court is expected to be handed down by June of 2010.
Absolute Immunity was first created in Federal law in the 1990’s, and was adopted in Kentucky only in 1993. At the time of the adoption of that doctrine in Ky. Justices Leibson, Combs and Wintersheimer all dissented.
After the l993 Kentucky case, which failed to extend Absolute Immunity to the Investigatory Phase of a criminal prosecution, the General Assembly quickly adopted legislation which provides compensation for any jury verdicts against a prosecutor. This law also covers a Prosecutors legal expenses in defending such a claim...
A web-based destination for aggregated news and commentary related to public school education in Kentucky and related topics.
Thursday, December 10, 2009
Malicious Prosecution
Saturday, October 24, 2009
Former Teacher Says Life 'Ruined' by Student Sex Claims, Will Sue
This from the Enquirer:Acquitted Nicole Howell Denied Sex With StudentFrom Start; Didn't Stop Arrest, TrialFormer teacher Nicole Howell was found not guilty last week of having had a sexual relationship with a student, but that did not stop the rumor from destroying her career, getting her arrested and ruining her life, she said today.
Nicole Howell talks about the allegations that ruined her career.
"My life is ruined. Completely," Howell told "Good Morning America" in an exclusive interview. "My name has been dragged through the mud. I won't be able to teach again. Not because I did anything -- I did not -- but because of the situation."
Her ordeal started in December, when she was suspended from her job as a teacher and assistant cheerleading coach at a Kentucky high school after one of the male students, a 16-year-old football player, claimed the two had had a sexual relationship.Howell, 26, of Florence, denied that the encounters ever happened and argued that the only evidence against her were the ramblings of a high school kid who, at first, claimed the two had been involved in a threesome with another male student.
Investigators arrested Howell the next month on felony sex abuse charges.
"I think, honestly, it started because people overreacted," Howell said today. "They took something that they thought looked like what they wanted it to look like -- like a stereotype, 'a teacher is accused by a student,' and automatically, it happened. ... That's why I went to trial." ...
With no physical evidence presented at trial, it took jurors only 70 minutes to find Dayton High School teacher Nicole Howell not guilty of having sex with a 16-year-old student who played football.
The majority of the case hinged on whether jurors believed what the student claimed (he also contended the sex was consensual), or Howell, who took the stand in her own defense....
Howell's case was one of the first to be prosecuted under a more-stringent state law that makes it a felony for a person in authority to have even consensual sexual relations with someone under 18. In all other instances in Kentucky, the age of consent is considered to be 16....
Saturday, October 17, 2009
Howell Found Not Guilty in Sex Case
It took jurors only 70 minutes to find fired Dayton High School teacher Nicole Howell not guilty of having sex with a 16-year-old student who played football.
“The fact this jury of 12 Kenton County citizens deliberated just over an hour to come to this decision is very gratifying,”
Howell’s attorney, Eric Deters, said while fighting back tears just seconds after the verdict was read. Sheriff’s deputies told Howell’s family to restrain themselves after an explosion of cheers, fist-pumping and cries filled Kenton Circuit Judge Gregory Bartlett’s courtroom.
“I just cannot believe it is all over,” Howell said. “I don’t think I even realize how much it is all over. I don’t have to worry about it any more.” ...
Howell said after the verdict that she didn’t hold a grudge against the student, but that she felt “sad” for him.
Deters said the not guilty verdict was, in part, a statement about the sloppiness of the investigation and prosecution of Howell.
The trial was almost derailed on the second day because the dates prosecutors alleged the crime occurred were different on the indictment than what was claimed at trial. The discrepancy even drew the ire of Bartlett, who called it “sloppy.”
Then, on the jury instructions, the date was again wrong. Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Stefanie Kastner told jurors it was her fault that the instructions said the crime took place in 2009. It should have read 2008.Howell said the allegations have nearly destroyed her life.“Professionally and personally, I will never be able to get my reputation back,” she said. “Obviously, my main concern was to pursue the fact that I was innocent from the beginning. I did that. I’ve been vindicated.“From here on out, I’m just going to go home and enjoy my life.” ..
Deters admitted Howell’s version of events had some inconsistencies, but said she wasn’t the one who had to prove anything.“Remember, we do not have the burden of proof,” Deters said. “They have the entire burden of proof to prove my client guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Thursday, October 15, 2009
Howell maintains she didn't have sex with student
Former Dayton High School teacher Nicole Howell denied under oath Thursday that she every had any sexual relations with a former 16-year-old male student.
"No," she answered to each of a series of questions asked by her attorney about any sexual involvement with the boy.
In testimony earlier in the afternoon, her stepfather, Edward Joseph Baer, told the jury that it's possible the teenager could have been in her Covington apartment, but he didn't believe he went there.
"If Nicole said he was never there, he was never there," Baer testified. Earlier in the day a Covington police detective who investigated the charges said he believe Howell was lying when she said the teen had never been in her apartment.
Baer testified he didn't find it shocking that Howell had sent text messages to the boy and he didn't find it inappropriate if she called him at 1:30 or 2:30 in the morning. Testimony for the prosecution earlier in the trial revealed that the teacher had sent 430 text messages to the teen from Oct. 29, 2008 to Dec. 2, 2008 and that the teen had sent texted Howell 368 times.This from the Enquirer, Photo by Patrick Reddy:
Ex-teacher takes stand
Former Dayton High School teacher Nicole Howell has taken the stand in her own defense against charges that she had a sexual relationship with a 16-year-old student at the school.
Howell, under questioning from her attorney Eric Deters, emphatically denied that she has ever had a sexual relationship with the student, or even held hands with or kissed him.
Earlier today, the prosecution rested it case with its final witness, Covington Detective Bryan Fodge.
Frodge continued to defend his investigation as he was cross examined for a second day by defense lawyer Eric Deters...
Ex-Teacher Denies Sex With Student
Detective Testifies Dayton Teacher Lied
Teacher Accused Of Sexual Misconduct Appears On TV
Detective: Accused Teacher Texted Teen 438 Times
Photos: The trial of Nicole Howell
Story from Wednesday's testimony
Story from Tuesday's proceedings
Since there is not physical evidence to back up the student’s claims, prosecutors are relying on telephone logs that show Howell sent 430 texts to the student from Oct. 29 through Dec. 1, 2008. The student responded with 360 texts to Howell during the same period. Those numbers don’t include 25 telephone calls between the two.That averages to about 24 calls or texts per day for little more than a month’s time.
The student testified Tuesday that he picked up Howell’s unattended mobile phone at the school one day and called himself in order to get her number. Howell said she initially had assumed that a cheerleader she coached had given the student her number.
Howell said she wanted to be a “confidante” to the cheerleaders and her students so she didn’t mind students calling her in the early morning hours if they were troubled.
“Did you ever text (the student) a single sexual explicit message such as ‘I want to have sex with you?’” Deters asked.
Howell answered again with a firm “No.” She said the concept of phone sex was “weird” to her.
The student, however, did send her sexually explicit messages, Howell said.She testified that she responded to those messages with sarcastic texts. When asked to give examples of her responses, she said they included “funny,” “yeah right,” “you wish” and “maybe when you are in college.”
She said she is sorry she never ordered him to stop sending the texts or discipline him for the inappropriate behavior.“I will regret that for the rest of my life,” Howell said. “That is why I am here today.”
The actual contents of the texts will not be known to jurors. Witnesses, including Howell, have testified that the phone company had purged the texts from the computer systems by the time of the allegations of misconduct made their way to authorities.
Witness places teacher with student
A Dayton High School senior testified Wednesday that he was flabbergasted when he spotted his friend and classmate after midnight walking through MainStrasse with an English teacher at the school.
He was the only witness during two days of testimony that places now-fired teacher, Nicole Howell, with the 16-year-old student she is accused of getting drunk, seducing and having repeated sex with...
The friend testified that he watched the victim meet Howell on a street corner late last year and then stroll down a side street with her into the darkness. How sure are you it was Howell, Kenton County Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney Casey Burns asked the friend.
“100 percent,” he responded...
The victim told his friend that he had a “code name” name for Howell so people wouldn’t learn of their forbidden relationship. The victim would call Howell by the name Heather, the friend testified.
Howell’s cell phone number was found saved in the victim’s phone under the name Heather, Covington police Detective Bryan Frodge (pictured above) said when he took the stand.Howell sent 430 texts to the victim from Oct. 29, 2008 through Dec. 1 of that year, Frodge said. The victim responded with 360 texts to Howell during the same period of time. Those numbers don’t include the 25 telephone calls between the two, Frodge said.
That averages to about 24 calls or texts per day between the pair during that period of time.
Another number dialed from Howell’s mobile phone was to a pizza restaurant on a date that the victim claims he ate pizza with Howell on the floor of her bedroom.
No records of the content of the texts have been presented at trial, but prosecutors and Deters both agree some were of a “sexual nature.” Deters has characterized the exchange as “sexting,” a term used to described sexually explicit text messages...
ABC News reported in July,
It's hard to imagine the jury buying "the platonic argument" if evidence shows her asking the student what “he had to work with in bed” and other sexually explicit comments.Howell says it not only never happened, but there is no evidence of other than the ramblings of a high school kid who at first claimed the two were involved in a threesome with another male student.
Howell is now planning to sue the school district, the police department and the boy who she says made it all up...
[Howell was] an assistant cheerleading coach, putting her right in the middle of a throng of cheerleaders and football players who practiced and socialized side-by-side.
Howell said the beginning of her first year as a teacher was going well until early December when she started hearing rumors in the hallway.
"There were a couple of students snickering about a teacher involved in a threesome," she said. Then the second boy who was supposedly involved, then a senior, told her the rumors were about himself, her and the accuser.
"I'm a first-year teacher," Howell said. "I didn't know what to do."So she sought the advice of a fellow teacher who told her to speak to the principal to get ahead of the rumor mill.
The principal, she said, "told me at the time ... usually these things die out. We'll look into it.'"
For a few days, it seemed like the matter had petered out.
Howell said she was told that both boys denied any sexual contact with her to the principal. Other rumors that followed, including that the accuser's father drove his son to her apartment for sex, was also disproved, Howell said.
But on Dec. 15 when she was suspended, Howell said the principal told her that the accuser, who had been threatened with possible expulsion for lying about such a serious allegation, had recanted his denial and was accusing Howell of having sex with him.
Howell said she left school in disbelief and hired a lawyer.
Howell said that while she knew who her accuser was and had interacted with him as part of the football-cheerleading team dynamic, she never once laid a hand on him or any other student, nor had she even been alone with him in school or otherwise.
Somehow, she said, the boy had gotten her cell phone number and the two had begun a series of platonic text messages in October and November. But Howell didn't think anything of it since 25 cheerleaders on the team had her number and texted messaged her also. And she knew of other teachers who texted with their students....
Howell told ABC News that she fears that even if the case is dropped or she's acquitted, she will never work as a teacher again once administrators see she's been charged with sexual abuse.
Her advice to other teachers? Be "super cautious" in every dealing with a student. "I worked so hard to get where I needed to be and start a career," she said. "And it just got ripped away."
Lat week the Herald-Leader reported that Kenton Circuit Judge Gregory Bartlett issued a gag order stopping attorneys from commenting on the case after defense attorney Eric Deters compared the prosecution's case to the prosecution of three Duke University athletes. Deters claimed prosecutors were trying to "intentionally and maliciously" destroy his client's life.
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Football Player Describes Sex with Teacher
This from the Kentucky Enquirer, Photo by Patrick Reddy :A former Dayton High School football player described ... in graphic detail sexual romps with an assistant cheerleading coach who also taught freshman English.The prosecution claims the student would sneak out of his house for late-night rendezvous with Howell.
The student testified in Kenton Circuit Court that the four or five sexual encounters at teacher Nicole Howell’s MainStrasse apartment during the winter of 2008 were consensual. The student was 16 at the time and Howell was 25...A change in Kentucky law last year makes it a felony for a teacher to have even consensual sex with a pupil who is under 18. First-degree sexual abuse is punishable by up to five years in prison...
The defense claims the student invented the story that “he bagged a teacher” so he could brag to his friends.
In court Wednesday, defense attorney Eric Deters finished his cross-examination of the teenager and asked for a dismissal, or mistrial, after he claimed the prosecutors had a timeline of the alleged affair wrong, but the trial continued. Howell could take the stand in her own defense as early as this afternoon.The student...[testified] about his encounters with Howell. He repeatedly used slang terms to describe Howell’s anatomy. And he testified extensively about sneaking out of his mother’s home at night, partying and spiking orange drinks with vodka.
He arrived at Howell’s house drunk at least one time, he testified. On two or three occasions, she provided the vodka, he said.
When asked what Howell said during sex, the student responded, “She called me Daddy.
”There were a couple of facts no one disputed: The student regularly participated in underage drinking and Howell used poor judgment by repeatedly sending him text messages.
The prosecution says those text messages, yet to be presented in court, contain the student texting Howell about her cute buttocks and her asking the student what “he had to work with in bed.”
When questioned by the defense why he couldn’t remember many details of the sexual encounters, the student repeatedly said, “I was drunk. I could barely stand.”
Backstory from KSN&C.
Friday, January 23, 2009
Teacher to face trial on sex charge

Time was when fooling around with a minor who was age 16 or older was only a misdemeanor. But a new law that took effect in July in Kentucky raised the age of consent from 16 to 18 when the adult is in a position of authority, such as a teacher.
According to police, Nicole Elizabeth Howell telephoned a 16-year-old boy after a high school football game and invited him to her house.
Now, she wants to apologize for her "bad judgment." She says nothing happened, but police wonder why it is the boy could describe a tattoo she sports on her backside.
This from On the Beat in the Bluegrass, photo from TeacherCrimes.com:
COVINGTON — A felony sex charge against a Northern Kentucky teacher can go forward, a judge has ruled.Attorney, Brian Halloran, tried to have the charge thrown out by arguing Howell never had the alleged victim in one of her classes. The law applies to adults who have a position of “control and influence” over their victims, he said. Howell wasn’t in a position to even influence the alleged victim’s grades, much less a supervisory role.
Prosecutors argued at a hearing in Covington on Tuesday that Dayton High School teacher Nicole Elizabeth Howell should be charged with first-degree sex abuse for allegedly having sex with a 16-year-old student.
Defense attorney Pat Moeves asked that the charge against his 25-year-old client be thrown out because the student wasn’t in any of her classes, The Kentucky Enquirer reported. “Our client didn’t exercise any undue influence or control over the alleged victim,” he said.
Kenton County prosecutor Brian Richmond countered that simply being a teacher put Howell in a position of authority...
Kenton District Judge Ken Easterling disagreed. If convicted Howell, 25, of Covington faces up to five years in prison.
To add to her troubles, yesterday the superintendent of Dayton Independent Schools Gary Rye fired Howell citing "conduct unbecoming of a teacher." Howell was a first-year English teacher at Dayton High School.
