Showing posts with label Fabio Zuluaga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fabio Zuluaga. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Old Business: KBE Settles Suit, FCPS Testing Allegation Resolved

A couple of old stories quietly wrapped up recently.


KDE Settles Suit with Ray & Associates

While we await the naming of the new search firm to help the board of education find Kentucky's next education commissioner...

You will recall that the state refused to pay bills submitted by Ray and Associates of Cedar Rapids, Iowa, the consulting firm that conducted a failed education commissioner search that produced Barbara Erwin.

State officials said the consulting firm conducted an "unsuccessful and discredited search" marred by a lack of thoroughness and accuracy in checking the candidates' backgrounds.

Former interim Commissioner Kevin Noland wrote to Ray & Associates President Gary Ray, noting the Board's initial payment of $15,030.44 but withholding the $33,734.77 balance.

According to KDE spokesperson Lisa Gross, late last year, KDE "settled with the company for $25,500, which is actually less than was owed to the group. This amount was agreed upon by both KDE and Ray & Associates."


FCPS Testing Allegation Upheld, Resolved

One spin off of the testing allegations brought against former Booker T Washington Academy Principal Peggy Petrilli involved an allegation being made against a FCPS director.

District Director, Fabio Zuluaga reportedly came into a classroom minutes after students completed the day's testing and began looking through student test booklets. The classroom teacher reportedly advised Zuluaga that it was a violation of testing protocols but according to the report, Zuluaga stated that he was “checking for completion” and continued to look through the booklets.

FCPS did not respond to a KSN&C request to address the accuracy of this report.

The teacher reported the event to the Building Assessment Coordinator who reported it to the District Assessment Coordinator. The district reported the violation to the state.

According to Lisa Gross, KDE "sent a letter to Stu Silberman in December" informing him that "The CATS Board of Review had determined that a violation of the Administration Code for Kentucky's Educational Assessment Program did occur."

Despite ignoring the teacher's warnings, the board of review found "that the violation was unintentional." Gross added, "since there was no evidence that any students gained testing advantages as a result, scores were not lowered."

"[Former] Commissioner [Jon] Draud recommend that Zuluaga participate in a minimum of three hours of Administration Code Training," Gross said.

Fayette County schools spokesperson Lisa Deffendall confirmed to KSN&C that "In accordance with the recommendations, additional training has been completed."

As KSN&C opined at the time, "a director flipping through test booklets, if full view of school faculty, staff and students, without a pencil, maybe ill-advised, inappropriate and embarrassing, but it does not rise to the level of a major violation. ... Refresher training for the director seems indicated and sufficient."

Increased pressure on school personnel to produce higher and higher numbers has proven to be counterproductive to the assessment system - which is being dismantled by the Genral Assembly at this hour. One wonders what impact testing violations, like this one, have had over time in undermining teachers' confidence in the CATS Assessment - and the public's confidence as well.

Wednesday, May 07, 2008

FCPS Responds to Report

On the heels of a Fayette County Schools report of an internal investigation of testing irregularities at the Booker T Washington Academy, Kentucky School News & Commentary reported a new allegation yesterday, this one involving an FCPS district director.

What is immediately apparent is that - not all testing allegations are equal.

This one comes at a bad time, and involves a top-level administrator, but it does not rise to the level of allegation we've seen at BTWA. Perhaps a KDE investigation will reveal more than we know at this point, but it seems unlikely that it will exceed the current allegation.

The BTWA report (posted at H-L) recounts school officials sequestered in a room, pencils in hand, and students being moved contrary to regulation - and during the week of the test.

By comparison, a director flipping through test booklets, if full view of school faculty, staff and students, without a pencil, maybe ill-advised, inappropriate and embarrassing, but it does not rise to the level of a major violation. It gives the unfortunate appearance of impropriety; looks bad, but it doesn't smell all that bad.

The teachers, BAC, DAC and anyone who followed regulations and ran some political risk by reporting on their superior should be commended; literally. A thank you note, perhaps. Refresher training for the director seems indicated and sufficient.

District spokeswoman Lisa Deffendall, responded to the KSN&C post:
There is a testing allegation regarding Fabio Zuluaga. But in talking with Fabio, it appears that some of the information you have is incorrect. As with any allegations we receive, without exception, we send the reports to the Kentucky Department of Education for their review

Deferring to the report is proper protocol. But it also means we'll only have one side of the story for a while.

But this story is not really about Zuluaga.

Today's educators have been asked (required by law) to produce historically unprecedented results for children - on an inadequate budget. The legislature is required by the constitution to provide sufficient funds for schools to reach their goals - but efforts to get the legislature to step up to the plate aren't going so well.

For the first time in history, starting somewhere around 1995, schools are attempting to assure a proficient education for each and every child in Kentucky. Left with scant resources for increasing teacher productivity and delivering more instruction to more students, many school administrators have turned to "motivation" to leverage better results - and like it or not - the test is the only yardstick.

This has had the tendency to focus people's attention on numbers rather than children. Having each school pick a target accountability index to hit, you can't blame teachers for believing that it is only the test that matters to the district - even if that's not exactly the intention. As long-time district director Bob McLaughlin used to say, "What gets inspected, gets respected." And test scores get inspected - published - ranked - discussed - cussed - and before long become the whole game.

Does this explain the BTWA situation?

Principals are, at once, the most vulnerable individual in the school, and the one charged with raising numbers. Add to that, the pomp and circumstance surrounding the creation of BTWA, the introduction of Peggy Petrilli in the position of principal-as-savior, all of the support from community groups, and it becomes easier to understand how much pressure was brought to making BTWA successful. And that meant better numbers.

It may be about kids. But the numbers are getting in the way of the district message.

~

Finally, KSN&C posted a quote from OEA investigator Doug Terry referring to allegations made against Petrilli "last year." Thinking like a school person, "last year" to me meant last school year. But perhaps not. Deffendall opined, "I think he must be talking about this situation from last August, which we just completed the investigation on." Well, I suppose that could be. Last August was in 2007 and it's accurate to say that was last year. KSN&C has requested documents. We'll see if anything comes of it.